BREAKING: Community Responds to BLM’s Approved RMP

By WSCC 3 years ago

Feds approve drilling plan for North Fork Valley that endangers communities 

BLM callously continues to favor oil and gas interests during COVID pandemic

For b-roll footage and high resolution photographs of the North Fork Valley, visit The Wilderness Society’s media resources page.

Contact: Ben Katz, Public Lands Program Director, Western Slope Conservation Center, (203)521-5134

Paonia, CO (April 10, 2020) — Today, the Bureau of Land Management released its Uncompahgre Field Office Resource Management Plan despite concerns and formal protests from stakeholders in the North Fork Valley and beyond. While Colorado’s governor and the public are focused on a major health crisis in the state, the BLM released a plan that could open up 95% of the public lands in the area to oil and gas development, threatening local farmers and businesses in the region. 

Community leaders say the plan fails to protect public health, provide ecological well-being, or promote a sustainable rural economy on Colorado’s Western Slope. These leaders say that at a time when small businesses are shutting their doors and communities of the rural Western Slope are telling visitors to stay away, the Trump Administration should not be barreling forward with land use planning that harms our community and environment.

The final plan, which the BLM began revising in 2010, is meant to guide all activities and development in the Uncompahgre Field Office planning area for the next two decades. Today we see the final plan opens the entirety of the North Fork Valley to oil and gas leasing and development while removing or limiting critical protections to safeguard the local community’s air, water, wilderness, and wildlife. Despite making minor changes at the request of Governor Polis, the plan is dramatically out of step with the protections local residents have requested for a decade.

The most disappointing aspect of the final plan is that it undermines years of collaboration and local engagement, completely disregarding a community crafted plan for the North Fork Valley. In 2014, a diverse group of North Fork stakeholders, including agricultural, tourism, realty, business, and conservation organizations, came together and developed a “community alternative” – essentially a locally grown vision and set of guidelines – for oil and gas management in the area. Called the North Fork Alternative Plan, the balanced proposal would allow for the consideration of regulated energy development on up to 25 percent of the area’s federal lands with additional protections for lands important to hunting, fishing, and other outdoor recreation activities. The agency’s final plan ignores this community proposal, and in turn, dismisses the community’s own vision for a sustainable future and diverse economy.

Recently released documents by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) through the Freedom of Information Act show beyond a doubt the final plan is the result of political maneuvering by the Trump administration to impose its “energy dominance” agenda on Colorado. The internal documents acquired by PEER reveal that Trump administration officials at the national BLM office overruled local agency staff and ignored local public input in order to “align the preferred alternative with administration priorities” such as deregulation of the oil and gas industry. Ironically, this decision comes at a time when the BLM is relocating its headquarters from Washington, DC to Grand Junction ostensibly to allegedly “delegate more responsibility to the field,” according to acting BLM Director William Perry Pendley.

The following are quotes from several organizations and stakeholders who have been working for decades to advance conservation efforts in Colorado and have been participating in the BLM UFO RMP revision process:

“An administration that supports a resilient local economy wouldn’t move forward with a plan that clearly disrespects the best interests of the North Fork community, yet this is exactly what’s happening. This plan is a triple threat: it ignores a decade’s worth of community input, it undermines our economic future, and it endangers the very public lands and waters that our local farms, ranches, vineyards, and recreation businesses depend on. As Colorado’s Western Slope residents and the rest of the country battle with a national emergency, the BLM is charging ahead to open lands that aren’t essential for the country’s oil and gas resources. Kicking our small businesses and communities while they’re down is just plain shameful.” – Patrick Dooling, Executive Director, Western Slope Conservation Center

“It’s disgraceful that Secretary Bernhardt and BLM Acting Director William Perry Pendley are using the COVID-19 pandemic as cover for their continued efforts to sell out our public lands. Coloradans are rightfully focused on the health and safety of our loved ones during this trying time, yet the BLM is jeopardizing the livelihoods of farmers and business owners who depend on this region’s beautiful land and pristine water.  Opening 95% of the lands in this area to potential development shows that the administration puts drilling above all else, no matter the cost to air, water or people’s way of life, or even our health.” – Jim Ramey, Colorado State Director, The Wilderness Society

“The Trump administration dropping this broadly opposed plan now, in the midst of a pandemic, only adds insult to the deep injury many North Fork farms and businesses are already suffering. We came together as a community and presented a plan to the BLM, which it has ignored in releasing this mess. We worked in good faith and that was betrayed, but we’re not done standing up for our farms and families.” – Pete Kolbenschlag, Executive Director, Colorado Farm & Food Alliance

“I grow food in the farm-to-table capital of Colorado, the Lower Gunnison watershed. Over the past nearly ten years I’ve worked to identify to the BLM what I need them to consider as they make their land-use decisions for the lands around and upstream of me. For my farm, and the nearly 100 other Valley Organic Growers Association (VOGA) producers in this valley, this means clean air, clean water, and an understanding that our reputation for clean delicious food is easily destroyed. I am disappointed that the BLM has ignored the agricultural community of the North Fork in its RMP, and has failed to listen to and consider the input we’ve worked hard to give them.”- Mark Waltermire, owner, Thistle Whistle Farms

“The North Fork Valley has felt the impacts of oil and gas development on our local economy before and has successfully diversified its economy away from fossil fuel development.  The real estate markets were thriving prior to COVID-19 and are holding steady with buyers continuing to close on properties they completed contracts on prior to the statewide lockdown. With this impending plan, the BLM is sending our community backwards, setting us up to be at the whims of the oil and gas industry development and threatening the local economy. At a time when we can’t even show homes or hold open houses due to COVID-19, the release of this plan feels like salt in the wound.” – Patti Kaech, Broker/Owner, Colorado Premier Partners Realty

“When the coal mines began to close, everyone said the sky was falling. Yet, we worked hard to build and diversify our local economy based on local business, renewable energy, sustainable outdoor recreation, and organic farming. We are stronger now and people are moving here to embrace this way of living, not to be surrounded by industrial oil and gas development. Despite that, the energy-dominance agenda the BLM has in mind is at odds with our vision of the future. Furthermore,the Trump Administration says they are here to help small businesses, yet seem to put another nail in our coffin at this unprecedented time. The BLM needs to re-engage with the community and develop a plan to protect the public lands in the North Fork Valley that support our diverse economy.” – Chelsea Bookout, co-owner, Remedy Juice and Cafe

“Right now, we have the opportunity to bolster a sustainable and long term recreation industry in the Lower Gunnison watershed. We have the wildlands, the community, and the ambition needed to develop and maintain a strong recreation sector of the local economy. Turning the valley into a short term oil and gas haven is not compatible with this local vision. The BLM must listen to the communities who will be most affected by this decision.” – Sven Edstrom, Chair, Delta Area Mountain Bikers

“President Trump has failed to take charge in addressing the COVID-19 pandemic, instead leaving it to the Governors to figure it out.  But as the documents acquired by PEER show, when it comes to oil and gas development and the UFO RMP, his administration is quick to overrule local wishes. The Bureau of Land Management must go back to the drawing board and consider the vision of local communities, and their own experts, in this planning process.” – Chandra Rosenthal, Rocky Mountain Director,  Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility

“The BLM’s Uncompahgre plan is a terrible disservice to conservation and support of local economies transitioning to sustainable recreation and agriculture. Secretary Bernhardt and acting BLM director William Perry Pendley have overwritten the locally-developed earlier plan to strip out conservation protections for wildlands and to grease the skids for their friends in the oil and gas and mining industries. Our public lands and local communities like Naturita and Hotchkiss will suffer the impacts.” – Scott Braden, Director, Colorado Wildlands Project

  News, Programs, Public Lands, Resources, Watershed
this post was shared 0 times


  • Betsy and Mick Johnson says:

    This makes me sick, especially knowing how hard so many North Fork folk worked to create and defend the North Fork Alternative. Thank you staff of the WSCC and all the other North Fork stakeholders for your blood, sweat and tears. Looks like we’ll be continuing the good fight parcel by parcel — in spite of a pandemic — to protect our land, water, air and us in the days ahead!

  • Deborah Bradford says:

    Please keep us posted on the best ways for us to fight this madness. Thank you!

  • Debra Deti says:

    What about the future of America for our children grandchildren and great-grandchildren and all the generations thereafter where will they go to get back to nature there won’t be any left I think we as Americans need to do something stop this Trump’s administration on this destruction have our nature and wide open spaces recreation camping and all the wildlife that that’s going to kill I think that this has been his agenda quite some time this is why he wanted to be president oil gas money control somehow we need to stand up as a nation and put a stop to this there has to be some sort of action that we can take other than just talk maybe we need to protest go back to the way it was in the 60s make a stand at least we know in our hearts that we tried thank you my name is Debbie and God bless America thank you

  • Cynthia Muscat says:

    24 million acres since 2017 have been leased by this administration. EPA Andrew Wheeler is no longer enforcing laws that protect wildlife species and habitats. While people are losing their lives…we are on the path to losing 100 million species in next two decades. Public input used to be part of the lease process. Even with the opportunity to have plans by the community, this administration rolls right over those rights. They are shameless.

  • John Dodson says:

    Trump is rolling back both regulations and protections in many areas around our great nation ! Too often without considering local communities to any extent if any at all ! Its as if an authoritarian government has taken cover control of our nation taking away community involvement & voices !

  • Steve says:

    I see that all the “collaboration” groups are all globalist organizations who hate human activity except their own selfish interests. I see no other groups involved that actually represent the local community. This is typical of globalist elitist pushing a agenda and pretending to represent the local community. Of course WSCC does not have any groups quoted from local community.

    • Dave Van Manen says:

      Groups quoted in the article include Western Slope Conservation Center, Delta Area Mountain Bikers, Colorado Wildlands Project, and Colorado Farm & Food Alliance. Not to mention local businesses like Remedy Juice and Cafe and Thistle Whistle Farms. These are not global elitist groups, these are people who live, work, raise families, and own businesses in western Colorado.

  • Carolyn Dalbow says:

    This is extremely discouraging and yet another good reason to get Trump out of office before he destroys the entire country. The collapse of oil prices might actually be a dis-incentive for more drilling, but it won’t last. I will write my senators and congressmen!